FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker vs Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary for "food diary"
FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker
Track meals, symptoms & identify food triggers. For IBS, FODMAP & gut health.
Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary
Diet & nutrition tracker with barcode scanner. Track food, calories, macros
Rank
4
For keyword
Rank
2
English (United States)Track meals, symptoms & identify food triggers. For IBS, FODMAP & gut health.
Diet & nutrition tracker with barcode scanner. Track food, calories, macros
Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary opens with "The Complete Weight Loss Solution" over a laurel "Loved by 31M people" badge, then shows barcode, AI-plate and macro screens with filled data. FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker owns the symptom angle a "food diary" searcher with gut issues wants, but its opening screen is type-only and two of four screens repeat the same Calendar view. The biggest gap is credibility: no number, badge or endorsement appears anywhere in the FoodLog set.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leadsFoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker's opening screen leads with abstract "Get clarity."; the concrete symptom promise only arrives on screenshot 2.
Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary states the payoff in three words, "The Complete Weight Loss Solution", above a calorie ring showing 480 left.
Clarity
B leadsScreenshot 2's Breakfast plus "stomach ache (Medium)" entry explains logging well, but screenshot 3 repeats the Calendar and screenshot 4 shows empty medication fields.
Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary demonstrates four distinct mechanics: barcode scan on a protein bar, AI labelling "Arugula" and "Tuna", and a macro pie chart.
Emotional Hook
Tied"Find the root cause." names the relief an IBS sufferer wants, but no screenshot shows a person, only a salmon bowl and UI frames.
"The Complete Weight Loss Solution" carries aspiration, yet screenshots 2 to 4 caption capabilities like "FREE Scanner" and "Track 100+ nutrients!" instead of feelings.
Trust Signals
B leadsAcross all four FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker screenshots there is no download count, dietitian endorsement, privacy badge or testimonial visible.
The laurel wreath "Loved by 31M people" on screenshot 1 puts a concrete user number in front of anyone browsing without reading further.
Reviews of FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker repeatedly describe entries failing to save, an inability to edit a meal's time or contents once it is submitted, and recent updates adding streaks and AI features that longtime users say complicated a previously simple log. Reviews of Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary are mostly positive, praising a generous free tier, barcode scanning with a large food database, and measurable weight loss, while the recurring complaints centre on being blocked at account creation and on premium upsells around features such as weight history. Both listings share a simplicity theme, but for FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker it appears as lost simplicity and for Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary as friction before the first screen.
App A
Pain points
Entries not saving
MediumCannot edit a saved entry or its time
MediumUpdates added streaks and AI over a simple log
MediumStrengths
Tracking without calorie counting
MediumSimple logging with no ads
MediumIdentifying food triggers and symptoms
MediumApp B
Pain points
Blocked at account creation
MediumPremium upsells and paywalled weight history
MediumBilling and refund disputes
LowStrengths
Generous free version
MediumBarcode scanning and macro tracking
MediumReported weight loss results over time
MediumFoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker positions itself as a diagnostic instrument for a medical condition, leading with "root cause investigation for your gut health" and explicitly setting itself against calorie counting. Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary positions itself as the proven, fastest general-purpose calorie tracker, leading with "1.4 lbs per week", "31 million users" and Forbes/NYT citations. The two listings compete for the same "food diary" query while promising different jobs: symptom causation versus weight-loss measurement, so the mismatch is one of buying motive, not feature overlap.
App A
Positioning
Clinical trigger-detection diary
Target audience
IBS, FODMAP and food-intolerance sufferers tracking digestive symptoms
Value promise
Pinpoint the exact foods causing bloating, reflux and gut symptoms
Tone
empathetic, symptom-led, lightly clinical
App B
Positioning
Proven mainstream calorie tracker
Target audience
Mainstream dieters counting calories and macros for weight loss
Value promise
Fastest, evidence-backed logging that produces measurable weekly weight loss
Tone
feature-focused, proof-driven, professional
Gap
FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker leads with symptom causation for a named condition, while Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary leads with measured weight-loss outcomes and third-party validation, so one listing sells an answer to "why do I feel this way" and the other sells accuracy and speed of logging.
Opportunity
Searchers typing "food diary" because of digestive discomfort rather than dieting find no condition-specific answer in Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary, giving FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker an uncontested claim on the symptom-driven half of that query.
Risk
The description widens from the IBS reader to "a food diary for the family" and "your entire family's well-being", which softens the condition-specific promise that made the first impression compelling; a reader deciding between a specialist and a general tracker may read the family framing as evidence the app is general after all.
Strategic advantage
The explicit FODMAP and intolerance framing lets FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker win the reader who is already following a dietitian-prescribed elimination protocol, a segment whose buying motive is symptom relief rather than weight change and who will not be persuaded by a calorie database's size.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing claims the clinical handoff: turning logged meals and symptoms into something a gastroenterologist or dietitian can read at an appointment. Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary cites experts as endorsers and FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker keeps the analysis self-directed, so no listing owns the space between the user and the clinician.
App A
41
FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker
Behind
B wins
App B
59
Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary
Strong lead
For food diary, Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary holds position 2 on proof rather than fit, opening with a "Loved by 31M people" badge, filled-data screens and reviews praising the free tier and barcode database. FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker sits at 4 with the sharper answer to the query but no credibility signal anywhere in its screenshot set.
Why it wins
Keyword optimisation is level between the two listings, so the food diary race is decided downstream: Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary pairs named numbers and third-party citations with reviews reporting measurable results, while reviews of FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker centre on entries that fail to save and meals that cannot be edited after submission.
Biggest opportunity
FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Tracker is the only side of this pair that answers "why do I feel this way", yet neither its title nor its short description names food diary, so the searcher's own words and one truthful proof point are the two things standing between rank 4 and a defensible claim on the query.
Next priority
Make the save path write offline-first with a visible confirmation and allow in-place editing of an existing entry's time and contents, since that is the recurring thread in recent reviews. Alongside it, the test worth running is a short description that names food diary in the searcher's own words, such as "Food diary for IBS: track meals & symptoms to find your food triggers".
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker freePeople also compared
Fitia: Calorie Counter & Diet
Calorie Counter - MyNetDiarycalorie tracker
Foodvisor - AI Calorie CounterCalorie Counter - MyNetDiarycalorie tracker
Cronometer: Calorie CounterCalorie Counter - MyNetDiarycalorie counter
Track - Calorie CounterCalorie Counter - MyNetDiarycalorie counter
Calorie Counter & Food TrackerCalorie Counter - MyNetDiaryfood tracker
BitePal: AI Calorie CounterCalorie Counter - MyNetDiarycalorie counter
Endive - IBS Food Diary
FoodLog: IBS & FODMAP Trackeribs tracker