Fishing Calendar & Tide Times vs Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time for "best fishing times"
Fishing Calendar & Tide Times
Catch more fish with solunar times, tide tables & marine weather.
Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time
Make your fishing and hunting effective with Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time!
Rank
4
For keyword
Rank
2
English (United States)Catch more fish with solunar times, tide tables & marine weather.
Make your fishing and hunting effective with Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time!
Fishing Calendar & Tide Times opens with a photographed angler holding a large striped bass under "Catch more fish!" and a 1,000,000+ badge, while Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time opens on a flat dashboard captioned "Best time for Fishing and Hunting in one app". Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time wins on feature legibility: its four captions each name a different screen (tides, weather, peak activity), whereas screenshot 3 of Fishing Calendar & Tide Times shows non-English weekday labels and never names tides visually. On desire and credibility the gap runs the other way and it runs wide.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
A leads"Catch more fish!" over a real catch photo, plus a 95% efficiency dial on screenshot 3, answers the search intent instantly.
"Best time for Fishing and Hunting in one app" matches the query wording, but splits the promise across two different sports.
Clarity
B leadsScreenshot 3's calendar carries non-English weekday labels, and tides appear only as a small "Tides" tag inside screenshot 4's location list.
Four captions map to four distinct screens, and the dashboard labels MAJOR TIME / MINOR TIME with exact bite windows like "4:46 AM - 7:46 AM".
Emotional Hook
A leadsScreenshot 1 shows a smiling angler holding a large striped bass at golden hour under "Catch more fish!" — outcome pictured and named.
Flat grass-and-tree borders frame raw dashboards, and captions such as "Peak Fish & Game Activity Times" name a capability rather than a catch.
Trust Signals
A leadsThe laurel-wreath badge on screenshot 1 states 1,000,000+ fishermen, a concrete number a browsing user sees before scrolling.
No download counts, testimonials, or badges appear across the four screenshots; the "Solunar Tables theory" basis sits only in the description.
Reviews of Fishing Calendar & Tide Times repeatedly praise prediction accuracy and simple day-planning, while the recurring friction is subscription pricing and charges appearing without a clear pre-download explanation, plus a smaller thread asking for in-app instructions. Reviews of Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time are dominated by accuracy of the major and minor solunar times and by users reporting many years of continued use, with smaller clusters about tide figures being off and about the Pro gate on adding locations. Both apps draw paywall comments, but the volume is noticeably higher for Fishing Calendar & Tide Times.
App A
Pain points
Subscription price resisted, one-time fee preferred
MediumUnexpected charges and pending refund replies
LowMissing instructions for reading the data
LowStrengths
Accurate bite-time predictions
MediumSimple, easy to use layout
MediumHelps plan the fishing day
MediumApp B
Pain points
Pro gate on adding locations manually
LowTide figures disputed by coastal users
LowUpdate reduced the forecast window
LowStrengths
Accurate major and minor solunar times
HighLong-term reliability over many years
MediumFree version already covers the essentials
LowFishing Calendar & Tide Times positions itself as a worldwide conditions engine that fuses solunar, tide and marine weather data into one scored answer about when to fish. Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time positions itself as a single-mechanism solunar table stretched across two outdoor activities, fishing and hunting, with tides added late as a bonus line. The mismatch is breadth of data versus breadth of activity: one widens what it measures for a single sport, the other widens the sports it serves around one measurement.
App A
Positioning
Multi-signal fishing conditions engine
Target audience
Freshwater and saltwater anglers planning trips worldwide
Value promise
Combines solunar, tide and weather into one fishing efficiency score
Tone
feature-rich, confident, benefit-led
App B
Positioning
Dual-activity solunar forecast table
Target audience
Anglers and hunters planning trips around feeding periods
Value promise
Solunar theory predicts feeding times for fish and wildlife
Tone
functional, checklist-driven, matter-of-fact
Gap
Fishing Calendar & Tide Times leads with layered data for one sport, stacking solunar, tides and marine weather into a single score, while Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time leads with one mechanism for two sports, applying solunar theory to "all types of fish and wildlife".
Opportunity
For a searcher typing "best fishing times", the fishing-only stance of Fishing Calendar & Tide Times can claim the specialist slot, since Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time spends half its title and subtitle on hunting.
Risk
The subtitle of Fishing Calendar & Tide Times spends its 80 characters listing three data sources rather than answering the question the search implies, so in a fast SERP scan it can read as a general marine utility next to a listing whose title says "Solunar Time" outright. Users who want a when-to-go answer, not a data suite, may tap the narrower-sounding option.
Strategic advantage
Tide tables for "thousands of stations worldwide" plus GPS spot saving is a coastal and estuary angler proposition, where bite timing depends on tide stage as much as moon phase, and Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time treats tides as a recently appended chart rather than a core signal.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing speaks to scarce fishing time: the angler with one free morning who needs to know which day and which hour is worth spending. Nor does either offer proof that the forecast held up, such as logging catches against the predicted window.
App A
60
Fishing Calendar & Tide Times
Strong lead
A wins
App B
40
Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time
Behind
Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time currently sits at rank 2 for best fishing times with Fishing Calendar & Tide Times at 4, but the underlying listing strength runs the other way. Fishing Calendar & Tide Times leads on positioning, first-screen persuasion and keyword fit, which makes this the most reversible ranking gap in the matchup.
Why it wins
Fishing Calendar & Tide Times answers what best fishing times actually asks, fusing solunar, tide and marine weather into one scored window, while Fishing & Hunting Solunar Time applies one mechanism across two sports and adds tides as a later line. Its store page also opens on a photographed angler with a 1,000,000+ badge instead of a flat dashboard, where the desire and credibility gap runs widest.
Biggest opportunity
Neither title nor short description on either side states best fishing times, so Fishing Calendar & Tide Times can claim the exact phrase in copy that its screenshots and positioning already back up.
Next priority
Test a short description that leads with best fishing times and the decision it drives, such as Know the best fishing times: solunar windows, tides & weather. (62 characters), pushing the three data sources behind the answer. The companion test is a first-launch screen naming the annual price and what stays free, since surprise-charge reports are the clearest drag on trust for Fishing Calendar & Tide Times.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker freePeople also compared
Fish & Tides: Bite Forecast
Fishing & Hunting Solunar Timefishing forecast
Fishing TimesFishing & Hunting Solunar Timebest fishing times
BassForecast: Fishing Forecast
Fishing Calendar & Tide Timesbest fishing times
Solunar Time: Hunt & FishFishing & Hunting Solunar Timehunting forecast
Deer Hunters MoonGuide 3.0Fishing & Hunting Solunar Timehunting calendar