Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma vs Asthma Tracker for "asthma tracker"
Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma
Forecast & manage your asthma with the AI-based peak flow meter
Asthma Tracker
Complete asthma tracker: Monitor symptoms, inhaler use & peak flow measurements
Rank
4
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Forecast & manage your asthma with the AI-based peak flow meter
Complete asthma tracker: Monitor symptoms, inhaler use & peak flow measurements
Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma sells a forecast the category rarely offers, peaking with "73% chance to be in the GREEN ZONE" on its third screenshot. Asthma Tracker answers the query more literally and shows the actual log screen, with severity chips and Peak Flow 520 readable on its first screenshot. The gap is that Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma opens on an abstract dandelion and the phrase "blow into the device", which leaves the hardware question open at the exact moment a searcher decides.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
A leadsSmart Asthma: Forecast Asthma's third screenshot promises a forecast: "73% chance to be in the GREEN ZONE" tomorrow, a benefit beyond logging.
Asthma Tracker's opening caption "Track Your Asthma" restates the category; the later screens name features rather than an outcome the searcher gains.
Clarity
B leads"Just blow into the device" over an abstract dandelion and a "PRESS TO START" dial leaves whether separate hardware is needed unclear.
Asthma Tracker's first screenshot shows real fields: Reliever Inhaler puffs, Shortness of Breath severity chips, Peak Flow 520, Oxygen 90; report sheets follow.
Emotional Hook
A leadsThe fourth screenshot's "Awesome job! What a result!" over a 94% green ring names relief, but no image shows a person living better.
Captions "Recognize Any Changes" and "Generate Printable Reports" sit over plain UI on a gradient; no person or moment of relief appears.
Trust Signals
TiedNo testimonials, download counts, or certification badges; the green "Asthma Action Plan" chip on the second screenshot is the only clinical cue.
Asthma Tracker's four screenshots carry no user counts, clinician endorsement, privacy badge, or testimonial; nothing credibility-related is surfaced visually.
Reviews of Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma split between strong praise for ease of use and clinician-ready peak flow records, and recurring reports of the app crashing or refusing to open, Bluetooth pairing failures, and the meter needing bright light to take a reading. Reviews of Asthma Tracker are dominated by praise for customisable fields and doctor-facing reports, with the only repeated complaint being surprise at the short free trial and paywall. Both listings show users who want to record peak flow and share it with a doctor, but Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma carries far more hardware and stability friction because it depends on a paired device.
App A
Pain points
App crashes or will not open
MediumBluetooth meter not detected
MediumReadings need bright light
MediumStrengths
Simple daily peak flow logging
MediumRecords shared with clinicians
MediumResponsive customer support
MediumApp B
Pain points
Short free trial before payment
MediumStrengths
Customisable fields for symptoms and PEF
HighReports for medical appointments
HighSimple layout with reminders
MediumSmart Asthma: Forecast Asthma positions as a predictive medical system built around a companion hardware peak flow meter, leading with "World's first AI forecast" and attack prevention. Asthma Tracker positions as a complete, customisable self-log with doctor-shareable reports, leading with breadth and control over the data. The mismatch is prediction versus record-keeping: one sells what will happen next, the other sells what already happened, and a searcher typing "asthma tracker" is literally describing the second stance.
App A
Positioning
Predictive medical device system
Target audience
Asthma patients willing to use a peak flow device
Value promise
Forecast and prevent attacks before symptoms escalate, with clinician-shareable data
Tone
clinical-confident with a life-reclaiming opening
App B
Positioning
Customisable self-log diary
Target audience
Anyone managing asthma who wants a private diary
Value promise
Log symptoms, inhaler use and peak flow, then export for the doctor
Tone
feature-focused, practical, checklist-driven
Gap
Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma leads with prediction and hardware ("Predict Asthma and Beat it", the Smart Peak Flow device), while Asthma Tracker leads with customisable logging ("Define your own symptoms, treatments and measurements"), so the two answer different questions: what is coming versus what was recorded.
Opportunity
Because Asthma Tracker never claims to anticipate anything, Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma can own the forward-looking half of the query and reframe plain logging as effort that produces no warning.
Risk
The subtitle and description tie the core value to the Smart Peak Flow device ("works best with the Smart Peak Flow device"), so a searcher for "asthma tracker" expecting a free app may read the listing as a hardware purchase and leave; the word tracker or track also never appears in the title or subtitle, which weakens the match to the exact intent being searched.
Strategic advantage
The "CompEx events" inhaler-failure detection and the built-in Asthma Action Plan give Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma a clinical claim Asthma Tracker does not make, which matters most to patients whose control is unstable and who are preparing for an asthma review.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing speaks to the caregiver of a child with asthma as a primary audience; Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma buries it as one bullet ("Follow the lung function of a loved one") and Asthma Tracker does not mention it at all. Neither addresses the recently diagnosed or post-attack user, the moment when someone is most likely to search for an asthma app.
App A
58
Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma
Strong lead
A wins
App B
42
Asthma Tracker
Behind
Asthma Tracker holds position 1 for asthma tracker on the strength of a title that repeats the query word for word, but Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma is the deeper listing at position 4, ahead on store presence, screenshot clarity and positioning strength. The distance between them reads as a wording gap, not a product gap.
Why it wins
Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma carries the dominant positioning read and the stronger conversion story, selling a forecast the category rarely offers and peaking with "73% chance to be in the GREEN ZONE", while Asthma Tracker leads on literal query match and calmer reviews rather than listing depth. That is an advantage that compounds once a searcher opens the page, whereas an exact-match title only wins the click.
Biggest opportunity
Neither the title nor the short description of Smart Asthma: Forecast Asthma contains the words asthma tracker, so it competes for the term on relevance it never actually states, and claiming that phrase in the copy is the cheapest available gain at this position.
Next priority
Test a short description that opens on asthma tracker intent and lands the forecast in the same breath, such as "Asthma tracker that forecasts your green zone before an attack" (62 characters), which also moves the device out of the first thing a searcher reads. Run it alongside the stability and manual-entry work reviewers describe, since crash and pairing reports are what would erode any traffic the new wording brings in.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free