Shake and Strain Cocktails vs My Cocktail Bar for "bartender app"
Shake and Strain Cocktails
Find cocktail recipes utilising the bottles you have on hand.
My Cocktail Bar
The fast and practical app to help you make the best cocktails at home!
Rank
28
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Find cocktail recipes utilising the bottles you have on hand.
The fast and practical app to help you make the best cocktails at home!
"Shake and Strain Cocktails" wins the first impression for the query "bartender app": its opening screen carries the "BY STEVE THE BARTENDER" header, "Cocktail Recipes (537)" and an "ON MY BAR" filter, and every tile uses real bar photography. "My Cocktail Bar" looks dated with clipart glasses on white lists, but it is the only side that actually shows the mechanic, numbered Margarita steps, checked ingredients and "Missing Orange Juice" labels. The gap to close is functional proof and a visible credibility cue, not visual appeal.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
A leads"Shake and Strain Cocktails"'s first screenshot pairs "ON MY BAR" with "Cocktail Recipes (537)" under a Steve the Bartender header, matching "bartender app" instantly.
"My Cocktail Bar" conveys its make-with-what-you-have idea only indirectly, through tab labels and "Missing Orange Juice"; no screen states the benefit outright.
Clarity
B leads"Shake and Strain Cocktails" shows browse grids and a "Little Italy" page with a WATCH button, but never an ingredient list or method.
"My Cocktail Bar"'s Margarita screen lists five numbered steps plus checked ingredients, and "Missing Orange Juice" labels make the matching mechanic explicit.
Emotional Hook
A leadsThe "Little Italy" shot's rye bottles, wooden bar and coupe carry real mood, but no caption on any screenshot names an outcome.
"My Cocktail Bar"'s four screens use small clipart glass thumbnails on white lists, with no photography, no people, and no outcome copy.
Trust Signals
A leadsNamed creator attribution "BY STEVE THE BARTENDER" shows in the header and on apron photos; the 800,000-subscriber figure stays inside the description.
"My Cocktail Bar"'s four screenshots carry no badges, testimonials, review counts or named endorsements; credibility rests entirely on the store-rendered rating.
Reviews of Shake and Strain Cocktails split sharply around the redesign: many long-time users report that the update removed the search-by-ingredient filter and wiped saved ratings and notes, while the same review set praises the My Bar matching feature and the linked Steve the Bartender videos. Reviews of My Cocktail Bar are far more uniform, centring on editable and user-added recipes plus its use as a working reference for new bartenders, with the main recurring complaint being gaps in the recipe library. Both apps are praised for the same core mechanic of listing owned bottles and seeing what can be made.
App A
Pain points
Redesign removed ingredient search and cleared saved data
MediumGaps in the ingredient list block some drinks
MediumSubscription value questioned for locked recipes
LowStrengths
My Bar matches stocked bottles to makeable cocktails
HighRecipes linked to YouTube videos by Steve
MediumLarge recipe library with clear instructions
MediumApp B
Pain points
Missing recipes in the built-in library
MediumRequests for cross-device sync and recipe import or export
LowStrengths
Used as an on-shift reference by beginner bartenders
HighEditable recipes and user-added ingredients
MediumTracks stock and shows what can be made
MediumShake and Strain Cocktails positions as a creator-taught cocktail library, anchored to Steve the Bartender's 800,000-subscriber channel and per-recipe video, wrapped around a bottles-you-own matcher. My Cocktail Bar positions as a deliberately small home shortlist, explicitly rejecting the volume claim with "Do you really care about 9000 cocktails other applications offer?". Both lead their first impression with the same what-can-I-make-with-my-shelf mechanic, so on a "bartender app" search the tiles read as near-substitutes and the real separation stays buried in body copy.
App A
Positioning
Creator-led cocktail education
Target audience
Home mixers and bartenders following a YouTube instructor
Value promise
Instantly see which of 550+ cocktails your bottles allow, free
Tone
enthusiastic, creator-branded, instructional
App B
Positioning
Curated at-home bar shortlist
Target audience
Casual home hosts mixing drinks for friends
Value promise
Only the popular cocktails, matched to what you already own
Tone
plain, practical, feature-list driven
Gap
Shake and Strain Cocktails leads with a named human teacher and video mastery across 550 recipes, while My Cocktail Bar leads with curation and speed, arguing that a smaller hand-picked set beats a large catalogue.
Opportunity
Because My Cocktail Bar's stance is defined by what it leaves out, Shake and Strain Cocktails can own breadth plus instruction together: every recipe demonstrated on video, which curation-first copy cannot answer.
Risk
The subtitle "Find cocktail recipes utilising the bottles you have on hand" describes the same mechanic My Cocktail Bar sells, so at tile level on a "bartender app" result the two look interchangeable and the Steve the Bartender credibility that would decide the tap sits in paragraph two where scanning searchers rarely reach.
Strategic advantage
A named, verifiable instructor with an 800,000-subscriber following is the one asset a competing listing cannot copy, and it converts the skill-anxious segment: people who do not just want a recipe list but want to be shown how the drink is built.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing speaks to someone actually working a shift: fast spec recall behind the bar, batching, or building a house menu. Both frame the bar as a home shelf, leaving the working-bartender reading of the search term unclaimed.
App A
57
Shake and Strain Cocktails
Slight lead
A wins
App B
43
My Cocktail Bar
Slight gap
My Cocktail Bar holds position 1 for bartender app while Shake and Strain Cocktails sits at 28, but the listing evidence does not match that gap: Shake and Strain Cocktails leads on keyword fit, first impression and positioning depth. The rank reads as contestable rather than defended.
Why it wins
Shake and Strain Cocktails carries the search intent directly, with a named bartender, "Cocktail Recipes (537)" and real bar photography on the opening screen, while My Cocktail Bar argues for a deliberately small hand-picked set on clipart lists that read older. That relevance and credibility edge is why it scores ahead of My Cocktail Bar despite sitting far below it for the keyword.
Biggest opportunity
Neither title nor short description of Shake and Strain Cocktails names bartender app, and neither listing speaks to someone working a shift, so the working-bartender reading of the query is unclaimed by either side.
Next priority
Worth testing is a short description such as "The bartender app that shows you how: 550+ free videos, real bar recipes." (73 characters), which swaps a restatement of the shelf-matching mechanic for the instructor proof no rival listing can copy. Pairing that with the restored ingredient filter and an account-linked backup that reviewers keep asking for protects the trust score, the one soft spot in this lead.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free
