MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter
Track calories, macros & nutrition with AI. Log fitness, workouts & meals daily
Calorie Counter by Lose It!
Lose weight & reach your health goals with Lose It! diet app and food tracker!
Rank
2
For keyword
Rank
3
English (United States)Track calories, macros & nutrition with AI. Log fitness, workouts & meals daily
Lose weight & reach your health goals with Lose It! diet app and food tracker!
Both listings make calorie tracking obvious and show concrete UI, but "Calorie Counter by Lose It!" wins on persuasion: its first screenshot stacks named press logos ("AS SEEN ON" CNN, TODAY, People) and uses warm food photography, while "MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter" relies on flat blue UI mockups and an unattributed "#1" claim.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
Tied"MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter"'s first screenshot states "The #1 Food & Nutrition Tracking App" over a live calorie/macro dashboard, so the core benefit is unmistakable.
"Calorie Counter by Lose It!" pairs "Track Your Calories & Nutrition" with a dedicated "Lose Weight" outcome screen showing a -21 lbs chart, tying tracking to a goal.
Clarity
Tied"MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter" names features plainly: "Scan Your Food" with logged Avocado/Eggs and "Use Voice Logging", each on a real UI screen.
"Calorie Counter by Lose It!" shows "Snap a Photo of Your Meal" with live food recognition tags and a "Log Every Meal" budget screen, both functionally clear.
Emotional Hook
B leads"MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter"'s screenshots are flat blue UI mockups with feature-name captions ("Custom Reminders For GLP-1 Medication"); no lifestyle scene or outcome feeling is shown.
"Calorie Counter by Lose It!" uses warm food photography and outcome copy "Your Weight Loss Journey Starts Here" plus "Lose Weight", though no person is shown enjoying the result.
Trust Signals
B leads"MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter"'s only cue is the unattributed "#1 Food & Nutrition Tracking App" claim; no named press, testimonials, or download counts appear in the screenshots.
"Calorie Counter by Lose It!"'s first screenshot carries an "AS SEEN ON" row of named outlets: CNN, TODAY, People, Good Morning America, Women's Health.
Reviews for MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter are dominated by dissatisfaction with the recent UI redesign, alongside complaints that the barcode scanner now sits behind a paywall and reports of broken food search and frequent forced logouts; positives center on long-term weight-loss tracking. Reviews for Calorie Counter by Lose It! repeatedly cite ads appearing even for paying subscribers, a lengthy onboarding questionnaire, and unclear pricing, while many reviewers praise how easy it is to use for tracking calories.
App A
Pain points
New UI redesign harder to navigate
HighBarcode scanner moved behind paywall
MediumBroken food search and forced logouts
MediumStrengths
Supports long-term weight loss
MediumTrusted calorie counting over years
LowApp B
Pain points
Ads shown even with premium
MediumLong onboarding questionnaire before use
MediumUnclear pricing and trial cost
MediumStrengths
Easy to use for tracking calories
HighDrives measurable weight loss
MediumMyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter positions as a comprehensive AI-powered platform that tracks calories, macros, fitness, workouts and GLP-1 progress in one place, while Calorie Counter by Lose It! narrows to a single outcome, "Lose weight & reach your health goals" through calorie budgeting and deficit. The mismatch is breadth versus outcome: one sells everything-in-one-app, the other sells a clear weight-loss result, so a searcher's underlying motive decides which listing feels more on-target.
App A
Positioning
Comprehensive AI tracking platform
Target audience
Broad nutrition, macro and fitness trackers, incl. GLP-1 users
Value promise
Track calories, macros, fitness and GLP-1 in one AI app
Tone
feature-rich, authoritative
App B
Positioning
Weight-loss calorie counter
Target audience
People aiming to lose weight through dieting
Value promise
Reach weight-loss goals with a personalized calorie budget
Tone
outcome-focused, encouraging
Gap
MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter leads with breadth ("track it all in one place", AI, macros, fitness, GLP-1), while Calorie Counter by Lose It! leads with a single named outcome, "Lose weight" via calorie deficit.
Opportunity
For searchers who want more than weight loss (macro tracking, workout logging, GLP-1 medication support), MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter can own the all-in-one and medication-era angle that Calorie Counter by Lose It! never claims.
Risk
The MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter subtitle stacks five capabilities ("calories, macros & nutrition with AI. Log fitness, workouts & meals") without naming an outcome, so a weight-loss-motivated searcher may find Calorie Counter by Lose It!'s direct "Lose weight" promise more on-target and convert there instead.
Strategic advantage
MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter can lean on its GLP-1 journey support plus AI and #1-in-U.S. credibility to win data-driven and medication-supported dieters, a segment Calorie Counter by Lose It! does not address in its copy.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing puts GLP-1 / medication-supported weight management into its visible title or subtitle; MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter buries it in the description body and Calorie Counter by Lose It! omits it, leaving that emerging angle unclaimed at first impression.
App A
46
MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter
Slight gap
B wins
App B
54
Calorie Counter by Lose It!
Slight lead
For calorie counter, Calorie Counter by Lose It! holds the more defensible case even though MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter ranks one spot higher, because it converts the search into a named weight-loss outcome while MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter sells breadth. The rank-2 slot for MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter looks exposed on conversion and review sentiment, not on listing facts, where it is actually stronger.
Why it wins
Calorie Counter by Lose It! turns the calorie counter search into a single Lose weight promise, backs it with named press logos and warmer food photography, and draws easier-to-use reviews, while MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter leans on flat UI mockups, an unattributed #1 claim, and reviews dominated by redesign complaints.
Biggest opportunity
MyFitnessPal: Calorie Counter already carries calorie counter in its title, so the gain sits in conversion: its short description stacks five capabilities without naming the weight-loss outcome a searcher is chasing.
Next priority
The remaining test is whether a short description that leads with an outcome, like Count calories, lose weight & track macros with AI (50 chars), converts the calorie counter searcher faster than the current capability list, while keeping the calorie promise up front so ranking coverage holds.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free