Stitchart vs My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet for "knitting progress tracker"
Stitchart
Design, preview and track your knitting charts on your phone or tablet
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet
So Much More than a Row Counter: Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter, Ravelry...
Rank
12
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Design, preview and track your knitting charts on your phone or tablet
So Much More than a Row Counter: Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter, Ravelry...
For a "knitting progress tracker" search, Stitchart's first screenshot answers the query head-on with "Track your Chart Progress Row-by-Row Repeat-by-Repeat", but the remaining three pivot to chart design, lace symbols and preview. My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet stacks six labelled bubbles on its hero ("Timer", "Pattern Import", "Connect to Ravelry") and wraps every later shot in photographed yarn, so it reads as tracking-first and warmer. Neither listing surfaces a single trust cue above the description.
Scanned screenshots4 a ยท 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leadsScreenshot 1 nails "Track your Chart Progress", but screenshots 2-4 sell chart design; the name Stitchart carries no category cue.
"So Much More than a Row Counter!" plus six labelled bubbles states the tracking job and its scope before any scrolling.
Clarity
TiedScreenshot 1 shows live "Current Row 12" and "Pattern Repeats" fields; screenshot 3 shows the k3tog stitch-symbol palette.
Screenshot 2 shows four named counters with plus/minus dials and a "Change color" reminder row, matching its caption exactly.
Emotional Hook
B leadsAll four sit on the same flat navy field with feature captions; only "before you even cast-on" hints at a knitter's moment.
Screenshots 2-4 float the phone over photographed yarn skeins, craft-toned but captioned with features like "Special Highlighter", not outcomes.
Trust Signals
TiedNo download count, testimonial, award or community badge appears on any of the four screenshots or in the short description.
Only the "Connect to Ravelry" bubble on screenshot 1 hints at outside credibility; no counts, quotes or named endorsements.
Stitchart reviews cluster around praise for fast, intuitive chart design and the knitted preview, offset by recurring reports of crashes on larger canvases, ad gates on grid size, and missing crochet and specialty stitch symbols. My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet draws consistently positive recurring themes around pattern import from Ravelry, multiple simultaneous counters, and cross-device sync including smartwatches. The recurring complaints for My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet are lower-frequency: ad interruptions during counting, a timer that resets logged time, and battery drain.
App A
Pain points
Ad gate on grid size
MediumCrashes on large charts
MediumMissing crochet and specialty stitch symbols
MediumStrengths
Simple, intuitive chart creation
HighKnitted preview of the chart
MediumRow-by-row tracking while knitting
MediumApp B
Pain points
Ads interrupting counting
LowTimer resets logged project time
LowBattery drain during long sessions
LowStrengths
Pattern import and Ravelry library
HighMultiple counters per project
MediumCross-device sync including smartwatch
MediumStitchart positions itself as a chart authoring tool that happens to track, leading with "Design, capture and share knitting charts", while My Row Counter positions itself as a counting workbench that absorbs any pattern format, promising "So Much More than a Row Counter". For a search phrased as progress tracking, one listing frames tracking as a consequence of owning the chart, the other frames it as the product itself, which puts My Row Counter closer to the searcher's literal words and Stitchart closer to a narrower craft segment.
App A
Positioning
Chart design plus row tracking
Target audience
Knitters working colourwork and lace charts
Value promise
Create or capture a chart, then follow it row by row
Tone
functional, craft-practical
App B
Positioning
Counter-plus-everything workbench
Target audience
Knitters and crocheters following downloaded written patterns
Value promise
Import any pattern, count hands-free, and knit mistake-free
Tone
feature-dense, enthusiastic
Gap
Stitchart leads with authorship, "a chart design tool to help you capture or create", whereas My Row Counter leads with consumption of patterns other people wrote, "Download your patterns directly into the app, be it a webpage, a video or a pdf".
Opportunity
Stitchart can own the knitter who works from charts rather than written rows, a segment My Row Counter serves only through a "Vertical band highlight for Charts" feature buried mid-list rather than as a stated position.
Risk
The title "Stitchart" carries no craft or function word, and the tracking claim is scoped to charts the user has captured or built, so a searcher looking for a progress tracker may read Stitchart as a design app that will not help with the pattern already in hand, and skip it before the description loads.
Strategic advantage
Stitchart is the only one of the two whose tracking granularity is stated in chart terms, "row-by-row, repeat-by-repeat", which speaks directly to lace and colourwork knitters whose buying motive is not losing their place inside a repeat.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing addresses the long-project return: picking a shawl or sweater back up after weeks away and knowing exactly where you stopped. Both frame tracking as live, in-session counting, leaving multi-week work-in-progress memory unclaimed.
App A
31
Stitchart
Far behind
B wins
App B
69
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet
Dominant
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet holds rank 1 for knitting progress tracker while Stitchart sits at 12, and that gap looks defensible rather than incidental: one listing sells counting as the product, the other sells chart authorship that happens to include tracking. Stitchart wins the keyword-optimisation block on the page itself, but loses on store presence, review sentiment and positioning clarity, which is where searchers on this phrase actually decide.
Why it wins
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet names the craft and the function in its title, stacks "Timer", "Pattern Import" and "Connect to Ravelry" on the hero, and carries recurring review praise for pattern import and multi-counter sync, so intent, promise and proof all point the same way. Stitchart's competing signal is weakened by recurring reports of crashes on larger canvases and grid size gated behind rewarded video.
Biggest opportunity
Stitchart is the only one of the two whose tracking granularity is stated in chart terms, "row-by-row, repeat-by-repeat", and neither listing claims the long-project return, so the lace and colourwork knitter searching knitting progress tracker to find their place inside a repeat after weeks away is an audience currently unclaimed by either app.
Next priority
Test a short description that opens on the search phrase and keeps the repeat-level precision, such as "Knitting progress tracker for charts: row-by-row, repeat-by-repeat" (66 characters), since the current line leads on "Design, preview" before it reaches tracking. Pair that test with raising the free grid default so the crashes and ad-gate themes stop undercutting the promise once searchers arrive.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free