Knitting Counter: Row Tracker vs My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet for "knitting counter"
Knitting Counter: Row Tracker
Stitch & Row Count, Projects
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet
So Much More than a Row Counter: Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter, Ravelry...
Rank
4
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Stitch & Row Count, Projects
So Much More than a Row Counter: Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter, Ravelry...
Knitting Counter: Row Tracker wins the first impression for this exact query: the opening caption "Count Rows & Stitches with One Tap" sits over a large, legible "4 row 0 st" display, while My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet's first screenshot spends its space on five teal bubbles around a phone screen too small to read. My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet recovers on breadth and atmosphere, with photographed yarn skeins behind its second and third screenshots and "Connect to Ravelry" naming an outside platform knitters already trust. Neither listing shows a knitter, a finished garment, or any download count, so both leave the emotional and credibility layers to the description.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
A leadsKnitting Counter: Row Tracker's first caption "Count Rows & Stitches with One Tap" answers the search intent exactly, over a legible counter screen.
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet opens with "So Much More than a Row Counter!", a comparative claim; the phone screen behind it stays small.
Clarity
TiedKnitting Counter: Row Tracker's captions name functions plainly: "Timestamp Log Prevents Mistakes", "Highlighted Display on Shaping Rows", "Manage Counters for Each Project".
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet's bubbles name "Pattern Import", "Timer", "Connect to Ravelry"; the fourth screenshot shows a real annotated thumb-gusset pattern.
Emotional Hook
Tied"Timestamp Log Prevents Mistakes" carries relief in copy alone; no yarn, hands, or finished garment appears across Knitting Counter: Row Tracker's four shots.
Photographed yarn skeins behind My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet's second and third screenshots set craft mood, but captions name features rather than the knitter's outcome.
Trust Signals
B leadsNo download counts, testimonials, awards, or badges appear across Knitting Counter: Row Tracker's four screenshots; credibility rests entirely on the store-rendered rating.
"Connect to Ravelry" on My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet's first screenshot names a real external knitting platform; no testimonials or certification badges otherwise.
No reviews were available for Knitting Counter: Row Tracker, so no recurring themes could be extracted for it and its score reflects the absence of evidence rather than any judgement of the app. My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet draws consistent praise for pattern import and Ravelry sync, for running several custom counters at once, and for syncing across phone, tablet and smartwatch. Its recurring criticisms are narrower and less frequent: ad frequency in the free version, a timer that reverts logged project time, and battery use.
App A
Pain points
No recurring complaints found.
Strengths
No recurring praise found.
App B
Pain points
Ad frequency around the counter in the free version
LowTimer resets logged project time
LowBattery consumption during long sessions
LowStrengths
Pattern import and Ravelry library sync
HighMultiple custom counters for rows and repeats
MediumCross-device sync including smartwatch
Medium"Knitting Counter: Row Tracker" positions itself as a precision counting instrument, leading with count history and automatic shaping math for raglans, gussets and necklines. "My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet" positions itself as a full pattern workspace, leading with "IMPORT YOUR PATTERN", Ravelry access, highlighters and voice control. The mismatch is depth versus breadth: one sells accuracy inside the count, the other sells replacing the paper pattern entirely.
App A
Positioning
Precision counter with shaping math
Target audience
Knitters working shaped garments, sleeves, socks and necklines
Value promise
Never lose your place, and let the app do the increase math
Tone
feature-focused, reassuring, craft-literate
App B
Positioning
All-in-one pattern workspace
Target audience
Knitters and crocheters following PDF or Ravelry patterns
Value promise
Bring the pattern into the app and knit mistake-free, hands-free
Tone
feature-dense, enthusiastic, capability-led
Gap
"Knitting Counter: Row Tracker" leads with counting fidelity and automatic increase/decrease calculation, while "My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet" leads with pattern replacement via "Direct access to Ravelry", PDF annotation and voice control.
Opportunity
The shaping-calculation angle is unclaimed by "My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet", which offers multiple counters but never promises to compute stitch counts, leaving "Knitting Counter: Row Tracker" free to own the arithmetic knitters currently do on paper.
Risk
The title and short description of "Knitting Counter: Row Tracker" use three near-synonyms for the same idea ("Counter", "Row Tracker", "Row Count"), so the shaping calculator stays buried below the fold. In a search results list next to "So Much More than a Row Counter", it reads as the plainer of two options and risks losing the tap before its strongest feature is ever seen.
Strategic advantage
Automatic increase/decrease calculation framed around "raglan sleeves, sock gussets, necklines" speaks directly to garment and sock knitters, the segment that abandons projects over shaping errors and has the strongest reason to pay.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing sells returning to a stalled project: both describe in-session tracking, but neither promises you can pick up a half-finished sweater months later and know exactly where you stopped, despite cover photos, notes and archives being present in one description as unframed features.
App A
48
Knitting Counter: Row Tracker
Slight gap
B wins
App B
55
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet
Slight lead
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet holds position 1 for knitting counter while Knitting Counter: Row Tracker sits at 4, but the gap is built on listing depth and visible user proof rather than relevance to the query. Knitting Counter: Row Tracker is the more literal answer to that search, which makes rank 4 more contestable than the positions suggest.
Why it wins
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet backs its position with evidence a shopper can read: reviewers consistently credit pattern import with Ravelry sync, several counters running at once, and phone-to-watch syncing. Its listing carries the stronger store-presence signals, which sustains rank 1 for knitting counter even though its title spends its space on breadth instead of the query.
Biggest opportunity
Knitting Counter: Row Tracker already names knitting counter in its title and already wins the first screenshot for that exact query with "Count Rows & Stitches with One Tap", so the remaining gain is conversion: making the shaping calculator visible before the tap, not widening keyword coverage.
Next priority
The test worth running is whether the short description carries the shaping claim instead of restating the title, along the lines of "Knitting counter with auto raglan, gusset & neckline math" (57 characters), since automatic increase and decrease math is the one thing My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet does not promise to knitting counter shoppers. The second open lever is review evidence: with no reviews surfacing on the page, Knitting Counter: Row Tracker asks visitors to trust it on copy alone.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker freePeople also compared
Stitchart
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochetknitting progress tracker
Markup R-XPMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetstitch marker
Crochet Patterns & CounterMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetcrochet patterns
Yarnly - Crochet & Knit ToolsMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetcrochet tracker
Knitting & Crochet CounterMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetknitting counter app
Stitch Counter: Knit CrochetMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetknitting counter
KNITMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetknitting organizer
Stitch CounterMy Row Counter: Knit & Crochetstitch tracker