My Quilts vs Quilting Calculators for "quilting app"
My Quilts
Weaving creativity and memories in one app
Quilting Calculators
You'll soon wonder how you ever quilted without the 8 calculators in this app.
Rank
7
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Weaving creativity and memories in one app
You'll soon wonder how you ever quilted without the 8 calculators in this app.
Quilting Calculators wins the first impression: its opening screenshot names all eight tools and carries "from Robert Kaufman Fabrics", a real fabric-house endorsement. My Quilts spends its first slot on a logo card, then recovers with genuinely clear UI shots of the project form, the 42-project grid, and the quilter feed. My Quilts' strongest gap is trust: nothing verifiable is visible anywhere in its four screenshots.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leadsMy Quilts opens on a logo card reading "KILEYS QUILT ROOM"; the benefit copy only starts on the second screenshot.
Quilting Calculators' first screenshot lists all eight named tools, from "Backing and Batting" to "Bed Quilt Sizes", under a Robert Kaufman header.
Clarity
TiedMy Quilts shows real form fields, "PATTERN DESIGNER", "WAS THIS A GIFT?", plus a project grid counting "42 PROJECTS".
Quilting Calculators shows labelled inputs and a worked "Calculation 1: 18 pieces" diagram, so each tool's job is unambiguous.
Emotional Hook
A leadsMy Quilts pairs finished-quilt photos with "DISCOVER AND GET INSPIRED BY OTHER QUILTERS", though no quilter appears in any frame.
All four Quilting Calculators screenshots are calculator panels over fabric texture, with no caption naming an outcome or feeling.
Trust Signals
B leadsNo testimonial, install count, or badge appears across My Quilts' four screenshots; the "42 PROJECTS" counter is in-app data.
"from Robert Kaufman Fabrics" heads every Quilting Calculators screen, with a robertkaufman.com brand bar down the first screenshot's edge.
My Quilts draws consistent praise as a project journal for cataloguing finished and in-progress quilts, but its reviews repeatedly report account sign-up and login failures and a lack of any way to sort or reorder projects. Quilting Calculators is dominated by praise for fabric yardage math on borders, binding and backing, especially while shopping in a fabric store, with only scattered complaints about over-estimated yardage and a non-working in-app back button. Both apps serve quilters, but the recurring themes sit on opposite sides: My Quilts is praised for record-keeping and community while fighting onboarding reliability, Quilting Calculators is praised for accuracy and portability with few recurring issues.
App A
Pain points
Sign-up and login failures
MediumNo way to sort or reorder projects
MediumSlow loading of the app
LowStrengths
Project journal for finished and in-progress quilts
HighCommunity feed of other quilters
MediumEasy to use and keeps photos organised
MediumApp B
Pain points
Calculator hard to find after the store update
LowOver-estimated yardage on binding and borders
LowIn-app back button does not respond
LowStrengths
Yardage math for borders, binding and backing
HighTrusted in the fabric store
MediumYears of stable daily use
LowMy Quilts positions itself as a memory-keeping portfolio for finished and in-progress quilts, leading with "Weaving creativity and memories in one app" and a community-sharing promise. Quilting Calculators takes the opposite stance: a named, countable utility suite ("eight essential quilting calculators") backed by Robert Kaufman Fabrics and Quilters Paradise, sold on solving fabric math. The mismatch is sentiment versus arithmetic, so a searcher for "quilting app" sees one listing that promises feeling and one that promises a specific unblocked task.
App A
Positioning
Quilt portfolio and memory keeper
Target audience
Hobby quilters who want to document and share projects
Value promise
Record every project, organise it, and show it to a community
Tone
warm, aspirational, exclamation-heavy
App B
Positioning
Task-specific calculator suite
Target audience
Working quilters cutting fabric in US or metric units
Value promise
Master quilting math: backing, binding, yardage, piece counts
Tone
feature-focused, practical, brand-backed
Gap
My Quilts leads with memory and community ("Capture, Share, and Organize Your Quilting Journey"), while Quilting Calculators leads with a countable job to be done (eight named calculators plus fabric-industry endorsement), so one listing sells an identity and the other sells a solved problem.
Opportunity
Nothing in Quilting Calculators addresses the quilt after it is cut and sewn, which leaves the project-record and finished-work archive entirely to My Quilts if it names that job as plainly as the calculator listing names its own.
Risk
The first impression from My Quilts, the title plus "Weaving creativity and memories in one app", never states what the app actually does, so a searcher comparing it against a listing that promises binding and backing math has no concrete reason to tap, and abstract phrasing like "Unleash Your Creative Quilting Potential" reads as sentiment rather than capability.
Strategic advantage
My Quilts owns the longitudinal record: fabric choices, progress, and completion dates across a whole portfolio, filterable by technique, fabric type, and size. That matters to prolific quilters and guild members who lose track of what they used on which quilt, a motive no calculator addresses.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing claims fabric stash inventory, the standing question of what yardage is already at home and whether it is enough for the next quilt, which sits between the calculator side and the project-record side. Neither speaks to the gift or heirloom quilt either, where the record of who a quilt was made for is the point.
App A
33
My Quilts
Far behind
B wins
App B
67
Quilting Calculators
Dominant
Quilting Calculators holds rank 1 for quilting app and the position looks defensible: it sells a countable job to be done, eight named calculators carrying a Robert Kaufman Fabrics endorsement, while My Quilts sits at rank 7 with a listing that opens on a logo card and a metaphor. The gap is not depth of product, it is that My Quilts never states what it does before a searcher decides.
Why it wins
Quilting Calculators turns a quilting app search into an unblocked task, binding and backing yardage while standing in a fabric store, and its reviews echo that same accuracy claim back. My Quilts leads with "Weaving creativity and memories in one app", shows nothing verifiable across its four screenshots, and carries repeated reports of sign-up and login failures at the exact moment a new install arrives.
Biggest opportunity
My Quilts owns the longitudinal record no calculator addresses, fabric choices and finish dates across a whole portfolio, and neither listing claims fabric stash inventory, the standing question that sits directly between both sides of the quilting app result.
Next priority
Repair the sign-up and login errors reviewers describe, since that is where quilting app installs are lost before first use. Then test a short description that names the category outright, for example "Quilting app for logging quilts: photos, fabrics and finish dates" (65 characters), against the current metaphor.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free
