Soapmate - Soap Calculator vs Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc for "soap making"
Soapmate - Soap Calculator
Soapmate, your soapmaking calculator & recipe app made by Cikgu Mimin
Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc
Soap recipes builder with lye soap calculators, batch maker & inventory tracker
Rank
3
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Soapmate, your soapmaking calculator & recipe app made by Cikgu Mimin
Soap recipes builder with lye soap calculators, batch maker & inventory tracker
"Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc" opens with a photograph of finished handmade bars and a plain-language promise, "Simple, yet powerful soapmaking software right on your mobile", while "Soapmate - Soap Calculator" opens straight into a pastel UI frame. Both listings show real calculator screens with oil tables and NaOH/KOH purity fields, so feature clarity is level, but "Soapmate - Soap Calculator" spends its fourth slot on a dark-theme showcase where "Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc" spends its fourth on inventory and supplier tracking. Neither listing surfaces a trust cue a browsing user can see without opening the description.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leads"Soapmate - Soap Calculator" opens with "MAKE YOUR OWN SOAP RECIPE", but the short description spends words on "made by Cikgu Mimin" instead of capability.
"Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc" states the whole offer on screenshot 2, "Simple, yet powerful soapmaking software right on your mobile", above a finished-soap hero.
Clarity
TiedScreenshot 2 shows a real oil table with percentages, grams and "Total NaOH Weight 30.12 gr"; captions name recipe calculation and public visibility.
"Create recipes" shows the Recipe Builder with Bubbly Lather and Hardness values; "Track inventory" shows a supplier and invoice purchase form.
Emotional Hook
B leadsAll four "Soapmate - Soap Calculator" frames are UI on pastel blobs; screenshot 4 sells a dark theme, a capability rather than an outcome.
Screenshot 1 photographs cured swirl bars tied with twine beside lavender on wood, though the caption reads "Chocolate Swirl Soap" rather than naming a feeling.
Trust Signals
TiedThe lecturer credential sits in the description text only; screenshots 2 and 3 show a member check mark beside "Hafizh Anbiya", an author tag, not app credibility.
No testimonials, download counts, certification badges or named endorsements appear across the four "Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc" frames.
Soapmate - Soap Calculator draws a small but consistent set of reviews praising it as an accurate, self-contained soapmaking calculator, with one reviewer objecting to the account requirement and the limited unit options. Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc collects far more feedback and splits sharply: reviewers repeatedly report crashes and glitches, frustration with premium and subscription billing, and the account/offline requirement, while an equally recurring set praises how easy it is to use and its recipe creation and sharing features. Neither review set is large enough on the Soapmate - Soap Calculator side to confirm recurring complaints.
App A
Pain points
No recurring complaints found.
Strengths
Accurate standalone soapmaking calculations
HighApp B
Pain points
Recurring reports of crashes and instability
HighFrustration with premium billing and subscription-only pricing
MediumAccount login required, no offline access to recipes
MediumStrengths
Easy to use for everyday soapmaking
HighRecipe creation and sharing between soapmakers
MediumReplaces the web calculator soapmakers used before
MediumSoapmate - Soap Calculator positions itself as a beginner's guided calculator authored by a named chemistry lecturer, framing soapmaking as a journey to be simplified. Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc positions itself as an all-in-one business system, leading with "ALL IN ONE SOAPMAKING APP FOR YOUR BUSINESS OR HOBBY" and chaining recipe builder to batches to inventory. The mismatch is credibility-led simplicity versus workflow-led completeness: one sells who built the math, the other sells how far the app carries the maker after the math is done.
App A
Positioning
Beginner-friendly expert calculator
Target audience
New and hobby soapmakers wanting guided formulas
Value promise
Correct lye formulas and ready recipes, explained simply for beginners
Tone
warm, encouraging, credential-led
App B
Positioning
All-in-one soapmaking workflow
Target audience
Selling soapmakers managing recipes, batches and stock
Value promise
Run recipes, batches and inventory for a soap business in one app
Tone
feature-focused, operational, business-forward
Gap
Soapmate - Soap Calculator leads with the authority of its maker and ease for "a budding soapmaker", while Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc leads with operational scope, naming "batch maker & inventory tracker" in its first 80 characters.
Opportunity
The searcher who types "soap making" and has never handled lye is not shopping for inventory tracking, which leaves the first-batch-confidence position open for Soapmate - Soap Calculator to claim outright in the title area.
Risk
Soapmate - Soap Calculator spends its short description on "made by Cikgu Mimin", a name that carries no recognition outside Indonesia, so English-market users see a store card that says calculator twice and promises nothing, which weakens install intent against a listing that promises a whole workflow in the same space.
Strategic advantage
A named chemical engineering lecturer behind the saponification math is a trust claim no competitor listing here makes, and it matters most to first-time makers whose buying motive is not getting the lye ratio wrong.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing addresses the specific anxiety of handling caustic lye or the fear of a batch seizing, and neither offers troubleshooting for a failed soap, an underserved angle for the person whose first attempt did not set.
App A
36
Soapmate - Soap Calculator
Behind
B wins
App B
64
Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc
Strong lead
Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc holds rank 1 for soap making against Soapmate - Soap Calculator at rank 3, and the lead is defensible on positioning rather than product quality. Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc sells a whole workflow in the same 80 characters where Soapmate - Soap Calculator restates its own title.
Why it wins
Soapmaking Friend – Soap Calc names batch maker & inventory tracker in its first 80 characters and carries that promise through to screenshots showing inventory and supplier tracking, matching the broad intent behind soap making better than a calculator-only frame. Its listing does the ranking work despite reviewers repeatedly reporting crashes and billing friction, where Soapmate - Soap Calculator's smaller review set is the cleaner one.
Biggest opportunity
Soapmate - Soap Calculator's short description already includes soap making as soapmaking, so the gain is not coverage but conversion: the slot currently spends its strongest words on made by Cikgu Mimin, a credential that reads as authority only to readers who recognise the name, while the underlying claim, a chemical engineering lecturer behind the saponification math, is the one trust cue neither listing surfaces.
Next priority
Test a short description that leads with the credential as a role rather than a name, such as "Soap making calculator by a chemical engineering lecturer, safe for beginners" (76 characters), against the current line. The review advantage Soapmate - Soap Calculator holds on accuracy is worth pairing with this, since crash and subscription complaints are the live weakness on the other side of this soap making matchup.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free