Simple Weight Tracker vs Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator for "body weight tracker"
Simple Weight Tracker
Weight tracker app. Track & record body weight in weight loss calendar.
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator
Track weight & BMI. Plan, set goals, log measurements & reach your ideal weight.
Rank
6
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Weight tracker app. Track & record body weight in weight loss calendar.
Track weight & BMI. Plan, set goals, log measurements & reach your ideal weight.
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator frames every screenshot with a headline ("Weigh-In and Feel Better", "Calculate BMI") and closes with before/after transformation photos, so the benefit lands before any tapping. Simple Weight Tracker shows four uncaptioned device screens: a downward weight chart, an add-record dialog, a lockscreen reminder and a goal tab with "Forecast Nov 20". The underlying features are comparable, but only one listing tells a story in the thumbnail strip.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leadsSimple Weight Tracker's goal screen shows "Gone 6.6lb", "Left 2.3lb", 74% complete, but no caption states the payoff anywhere.
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator's first screenshot pairs "Weigh-In and Feel Better" with a progress ring showing Start 137.3, Goal 127.9 lbs.
Clarity
B leadsReal functionality is visible: an "Add a record" dialog with weight and date, plus a lockscreen "Weight reminder", though no caption names either feature.
Captions "Calculate BMI" and "Set Your Weight Plan" sit directly above the matching UI, including the BMI dial and weekly pace table.
Emotional Hook
B leadsAll four Simple Weight Tracker screenshots are raw dark-theme UI; no person, scene, or outcome line appears, leaving the feeling for the viewer to supply.
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator's fourth screenshot shows before/after waist-measuring photos, and its opener names the feeling: "Weigh-In and Feel Better".
Trust Signals
TiedNo testimonials, download counts, privacy badges or compliance marks appear across Simple Weight Tracker's four screenshots or its short description.
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator shows no badges or testimonials either; the clinical BMI category table is reference data, not an external endorsement.
Simple Weight Tracker earns repeated praise for being deliberately minimal, ad-free and graph-first, with many reviewers writing that it does exactly what its name says, but a cluster of recent reviews reports that the date field under 'Add a record' is greyed out so no weight can be logged, plus several reports of entries disappearing after a premium purchase and restore failing. Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator is praised for its clean interface, its challenges feature and its lifetime purchase price, while recurring complaints centre on missing Google Fit and Health Connect sync, frequent upgrade prompts, and backups that cannot be imported again. Both listings share a core strength: reviewers on each side describe the weight graph as the thing that keeps them motivated.
App A
Pain points
Greyed-out dates block new weigh-ins
MediumHistory lost after premium purchase
LowNo way to edit a mistyped entry
LowStrengths
Minimal scope, weight tracking only
HighAd-free, offline, no account needed
MediumReadable long-term weight graph
MediumApp B
Pain points
Missing Google Fit and Health Connect sync
MediumRepeated upgrade prompts
MediumOffline backup cannot be imported back
MediumStrengths
Challenges that sustain motivation
MediumClean interface that is easy to use
MediumLifetime purchase seen as fair value
LowSimple Weight Tracker stakes out the diet-experiment lane: a weight loss calendar plus charts meant to reveal which diet, keto, low carb or intermittent fasting, is working. Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator stakes out body composition breadth: BMI banding, waist and hip measurements, body fat percentage, and goals that run in both directions, lose weight, gain muscle. The mismatch is one listing selling a verdict on a diet and the other selling a fuller picture of the body, with only the second one visible in the title itself.
App A
Positioning
Diet-tracking weight calendar
Target audience
Dieters trying keto, low carb or fasting plans
Value promise
Log weight often and find out which diet actually works
Tone
plain, functional, weight-loss driven
App B
Positioning
Body composition measurement suite
Target audience
People chasing a target weight, cutting or bulking
Value promise
Track BMI, measurements and body fat, not just the scale
Tone
structured, coaching, mildly motivational
Gap
Simple Weight Tracker leads with a weight loss calendar and diet comparison, while Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator leads with body composition, BMI bands, waist and hip measurements and body fat percentage, so one promises a verdict on a diet and the other promises a fuller measurement set.
Opportunity
Nobody in this pair claims the diet-comparison verdict in a visible surface, so Simple Weight Tracker can move what diet works for you out of the description body and into the title and short description where the store search result actually shows it.
Risk
Simple Weight Tracker's title and short description repeat the phrase weight tracker three times and add only weight loss calendar, so a user scanning a search result for body weight tracker sees no capability the neighbouring listing does not already show, and repetition tends to read as a narrower feature set rather than a simpler one.
Strategic advantage
The charts-plus-statistics framing that names keto, low carb and intermittent fasting speaks directly to serial dieters who have already tried several plans and want evidence about which one moved the number, a buying motive that a BMI band and a waist measurement do not address.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing says anything about where the data lives, no account, no sync, no cloud, and body weight is data many users prefer to keep local, so private, offline logging is an unclaimed trust angle in this pair.
App A
41
Simple Weight Tracker
Behind
B wins
App B
59
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator
Strong lead
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator holds position 1 for body weight tracker while Simple Weight Tracker sits at 6, and that gap rests on conversion and positioning rather than on a wider feature set. Simple Weight Tracker carries the better keyword fit and the better review sentiment of the two, so the lead is real but not locked.
Why it wins
Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator captions every screenshot, Weigh-In and Feel Better, Calculate BMI, and closes on before/after photos, so a searcher landing from body weight tracker reads a benefit before reading a feature list. Its title also states the body-composition promise, BMI and measurements, that Simple Weight Tracker leaves inside the description.
Biggest opportunity
Simple Weight Tracker's copy already carries the body weight tracker terms and it out-scores Weight Tracker, BMI Calculator on both keyword optimisation and review sentiment, so the whole remaining gain sits in conversion: getting the diet-verdict promise into the thumbnail strip and the first line, not into the description.
Next priority
The remaining test is whether a short description that names the payoff instead of restating the category, such as Body weight tracker: see which diet works, keto, low carb or fasting. (69 characters), converts better on body weight tracker traffic at position 6. Pairing that test with a fix for the date-picker regression that 1-star reviewers on 3.8.9 and 3.7.10 describe protects the trust advantage Simple Weight Tracker currently holds.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free
