My Filaments vs 3D Print Filament Tracker for "filament manager"
My Filaments
RFID filament manager for QIDI, OPT & more. Track spools, weight & stats.
3D Print Filament Tracker
Spool and Filament inventory
Rank
4
For keyword
Rank
3
English (United States)RFID filament manager for QIDI, OPT & more. Track spools, weight & stats.
Spool and Filament inventory
My Filaments shows deeper functionality, the "Write Tag" and "Read Tag" chips and the OpenPrintTag scan detail, but ships four uncaptioned raw device frames complete with the Android nav bar. 3D Print Filament Tracker frames every shot with a headline like "Track Your Entire Filament Collection", so the browsing user reads a benefit before tapping. Neither listing surfaces any trust cue in the images.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leadsShort description names "RFID filament manager for QIDI", but screenshot 1 opens on a bare spool list with no headline.
Screenshot 1 headline "Track Your Entire Filament Collection" plus "Log Weight, Color, and Material in Seconds" states the payoff before any tap.
Clarity
A leads"Write Tag" / "Read Tag" chips, the New Filament form's Vendor and Material fields, and Nominal Length plus Preheat Temp show exactly what happens.
Screenshots 1 and 2 repeat the same spool grid, and "Compare Prices and Save" sits over a Usage Statistics panel, not a price screen.
Emotional Hook
TiedFour uncropped device captures, including an all-"All" empty Filters sheet and the visible Airplane mode status bar, carry no outcome copy.
Captions name capabilities, "Visual Stats for Your Collection", and screenshot 4 spends a slot on a Dark Mode settings panel.
Trust Signals
TiedNo testimonials, download counts, or offline and privacy badges anywhere; the OpenPrintTag vendor chip is the only third-party name shown.
No badges or user-count claims; screenshot 4 instead exposes "App Version 1.0.0" and a "Clear All Data" destructive row.
Reviews of My Filaments split sharply: four of the eight sampled reviews object to full-screen ads appearing the moment a filament is added, while the positive ones consistently credit RFID tag writing for Qidi Box and general ease of use. Reviews of 3D Print Filament Tracker are largely positive about easy spool inventory tracking and the built-in filament database, with recurring requests around subscription-only pricing, search and colour-naming limits, and cross-device sync.
App A
Pain points
Full-screen ads during the add-filament flow
HighStrengths
RFID tag writing for Qidi Box owners
HighStraightforward day-to-day usability
HighApp B
Pain points
Search and colour naming limits in the database
HighSubscription pricing with no one-time option
MediumNo backup or sync across devices
MediumStrengths
Easy spool inventory tracking
HighBuilt-in filament database
MediumMy Filaments positions on hardware: the short description leads with "RFID filament manager for QIDI, OPT & more", making tag scanning and tap-to-update the reason to install. 3D Print Filament Tracker positions on a fear outcome and completeness, opening with "Never Run Out Mid-Print Again" and backing it with print logs, low-stock alerts and a brand database. The mismatch is input method versus coverage: one sells not having to type, the other sells having everything logged.
App A
Positioning
RFID-driven spool inventory
Target audience
Makers running RFID-tagged spools on QIDI or Open Print Tag
Value promise
Scan a tag instead of maintaining spreadsheets or scattered notes
Tone
feature-focused, enthusiast-facing, lightly emphatic
App B
Positioning
Complete tracking and logging
Target audience
Hobbyist 3D printers managing several spools manually
Value promise
Log every print and never run out of filament mid-job
Tone
reassurance-led headline, then systematic feature listing
Gap
My Filaments leads with hardware compatibility, naming QIDI Tech and Open Print Tag tags up front, while 3D Print Filament Tracker leads with outcome coverage, promising print history, cost tracking and low stock alerts so nothing is missed.
Opportunity
That leaves My Filaments free to own effortless data entry: a spool that updates itself on a phone tap is a different product story from one that asks the user to log each print by hand.
Risk
The title "My Filaments" carries no category word, so in a "filament manager" search the RFID angle only lands if the short description is read, and the RFID-first framing can read as conditional on owning tagged spools, costing installs from users with ordinary unlabelled spools who assume the app is not for them.
Strategic advantage
Tag writing plus tap-to-open, described as "friction-free workflow", is a concrete edge with QIDI and Open Print Tag owners, the segment buying on the promise of never typing a weight again.
Missed opportunity
Neither listing addresses filament condition: moisture, drying cycles and storage humidity go unmentioned even though both track storage location, an angle that matters to anyone printing PETG, TPU or nylon.
App A
49
My Filaments
Even
B wins
App B
51
3D Print Filament Tracker
Even
My Filaments and 3D Print Filament Tracker sit one position apart on filament manager, at 4 and 3, and the blocks are close enough that neither position is settled. 3D Print Filament Tracker holds the edge on listing facts and review sentiment, while My Filaments holds the sharper positioning, so the race turns on which side closes its weaker half first.
Why it wins
The split is clean: 3D Print Filament Tracker frames every screenshot with a benefit headline like "Track Your Entire Filament Collection" and draws calmer reviews, while My Filaments owns the hardware story with "RFID filament manager for QIDI, OPT & more" but carries four of eight sampled reviews objecting to full-screen ads. Review sentiment is the deciding factor for the filament manager slot, because both listings convert at the same level today.
Biggest opportunity
The short description of My Filaments already includes filament manager exactly, so the gain sits in conversion: the four uncaptioned device frames hide the tap-to-update RFID workflow that the copy sells, and headline captions would make that edge readable before the tap.
Next priority
Test pulling the interstitial ad out of the add-filament action, the exact moment reviewers describe, with a one-time ad-free purchase offered alongside the current model. Ratings recovery there is what would make rank 4 on filament manager defensible, since the hardware positioning is already the stronger of the two.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker freePeople also compared
SpoolTap – 3D Filament Tracker
3D Print Filament Trackerfilament tracker
Priamos3Dlab: Filament Manager3D Print Filament Trackerfilament manager
DrySpool: Filament Tracker3D Print Filament Trackerfilament tracker
Filament Depot - Spool Tracker3D Print Filament Trackerfilament tracker
Filament Genius: Spool Tracker3D Print Filament Trackerfilament manager
Spoolstock - 3D Printing Hub
My Filamentsfilament tracker