Knitting & Crochet Counter vs My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet for "knitting counter app"
Knitting & Crochet Counter
Row counter, yarn stash, needle inventory and project tracker — all in one app.
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet
So Much More than a Row Counter: Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter, Ravelry...
Rank
19
For keyword
Rank
1
English (United States)Row counter, yarn stash, needle inventory and project tracker — all in one app.
So Much More than a Row Counter: Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter, Ravelry...
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet sells its positioning in the first frame, "So Much More than a Row Counter!" over photographed yarn skeins, while Knitting & Crochet Counter ships four caption-free UI shots a scanning knitter has to decode alone. Knitting & Crochet Counter's screens are the more legible ones ("84 of 120", "Yarn stash"), and My Row Counter's iPhone device frames read oddly inside a Play listing. Captions plus one lifestyle frame would close most of the gap.
Scanned screenshots4 a · 4 b
Only the first 4 screenshots from each side are sent to the AI. These are what users see in App Store and Google Play search results, so they carry most of the conversion weight.
App A
App B
Value Proposition
B leadsKnitting & Crochet Counter's four screenshots carry no caption at all; the all-in-one promise lives only in the short description, not the visuals.
My Row Counter states its positioning outright in frame one, "So Much More than a Row Counter!", ringed by Timer, Pattern Import and Ravelry bubbles.
Clarity
TiedEach screen names its own job: "84 of 120" rows, "Cable repeat", "On the needles" project chips, gauge in st/rows, searchable "Yarn stash".
Captions name functions plainly: "add reminders to appear on a given row" and "Special Highlighter to follow your charts", over visible in-app chart UI.
Emotional Hook
B leadsWarm cream and terracotta UI with insider names "Autumn Socks" and "Malabrigo Rios", but no knitter imagery and no outcome line anywhere.
Photographed yarn skeins wrap every phone frame, yet captions name capabilities ("Several Highlighters") instead of the relief of never losing your place.
Trust Signals
TiedNo download count, testimonial, award or badge is surfaced visually; the offline and backup claims stay buried in the description text.
No testimonials, awards or user-count cues either; the "Connect to Ravelry" bubble is an integration callout rather than independent credibility.
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet draws consistent praise for pattern import and storage, especially saving PDFs and linking a Ravelry library, plus multiple simultaneous counters and repeat tracking. Its recurring complaints are lower frequency: app and timer glitches, ads interrupting the free version, and battery consumption. Knitting & Crochet Counter has no reviews in this sample, so no recurring themes can be identified for it.
App A
Pain points
No recurring complaints found.
Strengths
No recurring praise found.
App B
Pain points
App and timer glitches
LowAds interrupting the free counter
LowBattery consumption during long sessions
LowStrengths
Pattern storage and Ravelry linking
HighMultiple counters and repeat tracking
MediumEasy to use across every project
HighKnitting & Crochet Counter positions itself as the whole craft life in one place, leading with row counting plus yarn stash, needle inventory and project records in a cozy, offline frame. My Row Counter positions itself as the working session at the needle, promising "So Much More than a Row Counter" through pattern import, PDF annotation, chart highlighters and Wear OS control. The mismatch is scope versus depth: one listing sells everything a knitter owns, the other sells everything that happens while a pattern is open.
App A
Positioning
All-in-one craft life organiser
Target audience
Knitters and crocheters juggling several projects and a stash
Value promise
Counts, yarn, needles and projects kept together, offline and never lost
Tone
Warm, domestic, feature-complete
App B
Positioning
Pattern-following workbench
Target audience
Pattern knitters working from PDFs, charts and Ravelry
Value promise
Follow any imported pattern row by row without losing the line
Tone
Feature-forward, enthusiastic, instructional
Gap
Knitting & Crochet Counter leads with breadth across the craft, naming "yarn stash" and "needle inventory", while My Row Counter leads with depth inside one pattern, naming "Pattern Import, Timer, Highlighter" and annotation on PDFs.
Opportunity
A searcher for "knitting counter app" who also wants to stop re-buying yarn has only one listing that answers that need, so Knitting & Crochet Counter can own the stash-and-supplies buyer without contesting pattern tooling.
Risk
Knitting & Crochet Counter states "does not host or sell patterns" and offers only attach-your-own PDF or a Ravelry link, while the rival listing promises in-app import, row reminders and chart highlighting; pattern-driven knitters comparing the two may read the counter as adequate but the pattern workflow as thinner, and choose on that axis.
Strategic advantage
Nothing in the My Row Counter listing addresses yarn, needles, dye lots or gauge, so Knitting & Crochet Counter is the only option for stash keepers and multi-project crafters whose buying motive is inventory control, not pattern navigation.
Missed opportunity
Both listings sell hands-free counting as convenience, never as accessibility: big-tap targets, haptics, lock-screen counting and voice all serve knitters with limited vision or dexterity, and neither listing names that user.
App A
42
Knitting & Crochet Counter
Behind
B wins
App B
62
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet
Strong lead
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet holds position 1 for knitting counter app while Knitting & Crochet Counter sits at 19, and that gap is earned on store presence and review depth rather than sharper keyword targeting. Both listings optimise for the term equally well, which makes the ranking defensible today but not locked.
Why it wins
My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet converts the visit: the first frame sells "So Much More than a Row Counter!" and reviewers keep repeating the same concrete win, pattern import and a linked Ravelry library. Knitting & Crochet Counter shows four caption-free UI frames and carries no reviews in this sample, so a searcher scanning knitting counter app results has little to anchor trust on.
Biggest opportunity
The title of Knitting & Crochet Counter already carries knitting and counter for knitting counter app, so the gain sits in conversion rather than coverage: nothing in the My Row Counter: Knit & Crochet listing addresses yarn, needles, dye lots or gauge, leaving stash keepers entirely unclaimed.
Next priority
The remaining test is whether a short description leading with inventory plus hands-free counting, such as "Knitting counter app with yarn stash, needles, projects. Count without looking." (79 characters), converts knitting counter app traffic better than the current feature list. Captioning the four screenshots, with the legible progress screen first, is the paired test.
Run your own comparison
Compare more apps, in any market or language.
See AI recommendations on how to beat your competitor.
Track keyword rankings across every store and locale. Free to start.
Try AppTracker free